Recently, after I finished reading a book over the course of numerous bus rides, I asked my coworker
Darren to bring me a new book to read. I asked Darren because I knew he would take it seriously, and I was not disappointed. Darren came to work the next day with not one...not two...but three novels. One was his suggested read, one was his wife Christie's, and one was a "fallback option". Being a big fan of pitting spouses against each other, I figured, why not turn it into a competition and post the results for all to see on the Internet? Here are the results:
Darren's BookFrom the outset, the narrative of this book is striking. The 16-year old boy telling the story provides a non-stop flow of sarcasm and swear words almost throughout. I could see writing a three-page story in this kind of voice and having it be amusing for at least two of those pages. Yet somehow D.B.C Pierre not only kept it consistent and authentically sounding like a confused teenager for an entire novel, he used the voice to keep the story genuinely entertaining, surprisingly enlightening, and always funny. And what's more amazing, he took a naive, vulgar little man and made him genuinely likable. It takes very little time to become invested in Vernon Little and his well-being.
The story, too, is compelling. It follows this young man as he is railroaded in an investigation of a school shooting, carried out by a friend of his. Along the way, a surprising number of relevant topics are touched upon in a surprisingly telling fashion--the disturbing role of the media in our society, the lengths people go through to hide their troubles from others, etc. Unique, compelling, funny narrative: check. Thoughtful commentary on the issues of our times: check. By the time I finished this book, I was sure I had a winner without even reading Christie's book. But alas, I was wrong.
Christie's BookLike with Darren's book, the style of The Road was unique. I would describe it as minimalist and disjointed--there are no chapters, frequent breaks between scenes, no punctuation to differentiate dialog from the rest of the text. You might think that this style would be annoying, but it really fits the story. The book is set in post-apocalyptic Earth--not necessarily in the future, but after a major calamity for which you are definitely glad that you weren't present. Featuring a father and his son traveling through the resulting barren planet looking for a warmer climate, the novel is a fascinating depiction of their daily struggle for survival and tense and disturbing interactions with the other survivors whose paths they cross.
The most compelling part of this piece, however, is the way in which Cormac McCarthy distilled the parent-child relationship down to its very essence. It's heart wrenching but somehow familiar to watch this father, who wants to give his child all of the best things from a world that he will never know, be happy just to know that his son is alive after another frigid night.
I believe that most people would find this to be a great book (apparently it was one of Oprah's books, so at least Oprah liked it), but I may be a little biased. Part of the reason The Road hit so close to home for me was that the boy in the novel could easily be Cayden. While both children are kind and generous and sometimes too honest, the primary trait that links the two in my mind is the disturbingly mature understanding of topics like death and fear, and a willingness (eagerness?) to discuss them. Perhaps every parent with a child who can walk and talk will see his or her offspring in this role. But even if not, The Road is definitely worth a read.
Winner: ChristieI'll go on record right now and say that this was not a fair competition. The style and plot of these two books couldn't be a whole lot different. It's like asking two people to prepare you their favorite food, and having one prepare a main course while the other prepares dessert. How is one to compare the two? Despite the apples and oranges, there's no way I could not pick The Road as the winner. It is easily one of the best books I have read (note: I haven't read all that many books).
It is fairly common to find a book that you don't want to put down and that you find yourself thinking about while you're not reading; The Road, however, went a step further for me. I found myself having strange moments where the novel's world was somehow present in my own. I would look up at the sun behind an overcast sky and I was there in the clouds of ash. I would look at Cayden, then sick, trailing behind me on a sidewalk with his sweatshirt's hood hiding all but his tired looking eyes, and he was the boy from the story. It got a little eerie there for a while.
So while Christie and I may disagree on who our next president should be (she likes left and I prefer lefter), I will gladly take more reading suggestions from her. Or from Darren, for that matter.